Just when we thought Beyoncé’s songwriting scandals were a thing of the past, a background singer is now suing Beyoncé for $7 million claiming she stole his music for her song “XO.”
via Radar Online:
Queen Bey explained to the court the two tracks don’t even sound a little bit alike, and she mentioned that she has no need to steal since she has “17 Grammy awards and 118 million records sold.”
A background singer named Ahmad Lane filed the federal lawsuit last year against Knowles, her music company Parkwood Entertainment and Columbia Records, accusing Jay Z’s wife of stealing his music for her hit song “XO.” He claimed that he worked as a background singer with Knowles’ current background singer Chrissy Collins for another artist. During his time working with Collins he had given her a copy of his song “XOXO” to listen to and infers that she passed it along to Knowles.
On June 4, 2015, Knowles fired back at the background singer’s lawsuit claiming his complaint is a “vague and cryptic.” She explains that she is a internationally known singer who has won 17 Grammys and sold over 118 million albums
“The two works at issue are entirely different songs that share no lyrical or musical similarity, other than perhaps the letters “X” and “O.” The documents also state that Lane never filed a “copyright registration” for his song.
The documents claims that Lane’s description of the copyright infringement is due to the fact that Knowles’ song “allegedly copies the first four bars of an eight bar melody that is looped,” and “contains a four note sequence that is similar to the four note sequence,” in her song.
Knowles’ attorney writes asking the court to listen to the man’s song and compare it to hers and states that if anyone was to listen to both they would find the two works don’t share any, “melodic content and there is no meaningful similarity in pitch series, rhythm or rhythmic patterns, melodic development or structure”
Also, Knowles’ attorney states, “the two songs are distinct from a thematic perspective” with the man’s song describing the narrator’s romantic and sexual feelings towards a new lover. His song features lyrics talking about “being horny” and “wanting to love every inch of the lover’s body,” while her song is a “celebration of love and life, emphasizing the importance of living in the present with a loved one ‘before our time has run out.’”
We saw how the Marvin Gaye / Pharrell Williams “Blurred Lines” situation played out — let’s hope Bey isn’t found guilty!
[button color=”pink” size=”small” link=”http://radaronline.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Beyonce-Lawsuit.pdf” icon=”” target=”true”]Read the Court Documents[/button]